Calvary Orthodox Presbyterian Church of Harrisville, PA. came into existence in 1966 as a result of the joining together of the New Hope O.P.C. of Branchton and Faith O.P.C. of Harrisville. These two congregations had been one pastoral charge for many years in the Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A. They were organized as particular churches of our denomination under the leadership of the Rev. Robert L. Atwell in the first year of the denomination’s existence, and continued to share pastors until their union.In 1966, under the leadership of the Rev. George Morton, the two congregations united and chose the name “Calvary Orthodox Presbyterian Church”.
On May 1, 1966 ground was broken for a new building to serve the needs of the congregation. New Hope O.P. Church and Faith O.P. Church held joint services beginning in January 1966 in Faith Church building. (New Hope congregation actually met with Faith Church the last Sunday in December as their fuel oil had been stolen.) The two congregations officially united February 14, 1966. Harrisville had 99 adults and 56 covenant children. New Hope had 43 adults and 21 covenant children. Total 142 adults and 77 covenant children or a grand total of 219 persons.
Mrs. Kathleen Speer donated land for the building. The new building, larger, more attractive, with better facilities and located on the main road through Harrisville, has helped our witness in the area. The groundbreaking service for Calvary Church building was held May 1, 1966. Rev. George Morton (pastor), Elton Brown (President of the board of Trustees), O.D. Allison, J.E.Atwell, John Speer, William Speer, and 70 people were in attendance. The Hearing for the Charter application was July 28, 1966 before Judge Clyde S. Shumaker. The dedication service for the new Calvary Church building was held March 12, 1967 at 2:30 P.M. Rev. George Morton’s sermon was “If a Man Love Me”. A week of evening services followed.
In May of 1971 a group of parents and interested people formed a Christian School Association. In autumn of 1971 the Christian Public School of Western Pennsylvania began operation with 10 students in grades l through 3. The first term the school met in Grove City and the next two terms at Nashua Church. During these years parents from Calvary Church were active in support of the school and children from Calvary Church were students. The school met in Calvary Church since the 1974-75 term, while another school, Jubilee Christian School, continued to meet at Nashua Church. Grades had been added until the school had kindergarten through grade 8. The first 8th grade class to graduate was in 1978. Early in 1977 an addition to the church building was completed to house the school. This addtion to the building has been of great benefit to both the school and the congragation. In 1992, the school was dissolved.
One of the strengths of Calvary Church is that is situated in an where the population is not nearly so transient as in most cities. Many of the charter members stayed there until their death. There are grandchildren great-grandchildren of original members active in Calvary Church. The influence of Calvary Church reaches beyond our immediate area. One young man born in the church became an O.P.C. Pastor. Others who joined us in their youth have gone on to become pastors in other Reformed Churches. There are also ruling elders and deacons in the O.P.C. and other Reformed Churches who have been and some continue to be members of Calvary Church. As we look back on the history of Calvary Church it is with gratitude for faithful pastors, for each member God has called to our fellowship, and for His good hand upon us each step of the way. As we look to the future, it is with confidence that He will build His church, even through our feeble efforts.
Deacon History
Frank F. Karnes 0000 to 0000
William K. Speer 1972 – 1986
Robert L. Barnes 1972 to 1980
William Cypher 1972 to 1980
John E. Bennett, Sr. 1976 to Present
Lawernce E. Houston 1972 to 2005
Ronald Coulter 1972 to 1996
Dennis Ritenour 1980 to 1992
Dennis F. Blom, 1976 to Present
Richard Lane 1991 to 1997
Lawernce A. Houston 1991 to 2006
John E. Bennett Jr. 1991 to 2011
James W. Bennett 2011 to Present
Douglas Greenway 2011 to Present
Keith Rex 2011 to 2018
Keith J. Vinca 2011 to Present
Matthew Hemmerlin 2018 to Present
Matthew Vinca 2018 to Present
Jeremy Thomas 2023 to Present
Elder History
J. W. Gilmore 1936 – 1951
William E. McBride 1936 – 1952
W. T. Benedict 1936 – 1941
James B. Speer 1936 – 1949
Simion D. Morrison 1936 – 1950
A. W. Brandon 1936 – 1962
John H. Craig 1936 – 1971
Arthur A. Armour 1938 – 1989
James E. Atwell 1943 – 1966
Charles. A. Walter 1951 – 1970
William. H. Kiester 1953 – 2009
William K. Speer 1953 – 1965
Clifford H. Rea 1970 – 1973
Donald E. McCall 1965 – 1998
David Bovard* 1966 – 1975
Joseph Hockenberry* 1966 – 1969
Ray Ritenour* 1966 – 1971
Dr. Thomas F. Armour 1972 – Present
James E. Karns 1975 – Present
Robert L. Barnes 1980 – 2003
Jack A. Covert 1972 – 1991
Charles E. Fry, Jr. 1980 – 1988 and 2007 – 2018
James D. Bailey 1981 – Present
William S. Cypher, Sr. 1980 – 1982 and 1989 – 2003
Dennis R. Ritenour 1992 – 1997
Ralph Shay 1992 – 1992
Lawerence E. (Skip) Houston 2006 – 2017
Dr. Jay Colbert 2005 – 2006
John E. Bennett Jr. 2011 – Present
Dale A Hastings 2017 – Present
Donald E. Regis 2017 – Present
Nathan A. McAlister 2017 – Present
Keith R. Rex 2017 – Present
*New Hope Elders
Clerks of Session
William E. McBride 1936 – 1951
Arthur A. Armour 1951 to 1954
William H. Kiester 1954 to 2003
James D. Bailey 2003 to 2016
John E. Bennett Jr. 2016 – Present
Pastor History
The following pastors have served New Hope and Faith Churches, and after its organization, Calvary Church.
Robert L. Atwell 1936 to 1939
Jack Zandstra (stated supply) 1939 to 1940
Charles G. Schauffele 1940 to 1946
LeRoy B. Oliver 1947 to 1952
Frank Breisch 1952 to 1955
Cromwell G. Roskamp 1955 to 1960
George Morton 1961 to 1970
Leonard Coppes 1971 to 1982
Douglas Withington 1982 to 1987
Louis Wislocki 1988 to 1994
Allen Moran 1994 to 2000
Peter Puliatti 2001 to Present
Summer Assistants
Calvin Busch – 1938
Herbert Bird – 1945
Robert Eckardt, Sr.- 1946
Mark Neemczyk – 1973
David Kiester – 1974
Robert Harting – 1975
Larry Wilson – 1976
Douqlas Eckardt – 1977
Ralph Shay – 1978
Bryan Weaver – 1979
Stewart Lauer – 1980
Joshua Lauer – 2014